This Violence Which Is Not One
Taking Back the Power Stolen from Us
In the publication Ese sexo que no es uno (This Sex Which Is Not One, Akal, 2009), the philosopher Luce Irigaray sets out to travel through the monolithic representation of the sexual to recognise and liberate difference and multiplicity in pleasure. Under the title This Violence Which Is Not One, this encounter looks to emulate this defiant gesture, questioning a rigid imaginary of violence against women and the ideas of social justice associated with it.
Organised with La Laboratoria, this activity, part of a broader programme developed in parallel in Madrid, Terrasa and Manresa, is the outcome of a militant research process around systemic violence, set in motion by La Laboratoria two years ago through committed and situated dialogues in the cities of Quito, Buenos Aires, Porto Alegre, São Paulo and Madrid.
By way of a conversation and series of workshops conducted by researchers who have participated in this process, the activity reflects on the different manifestations of patriarchal violence (sexual, physical, economic, legal, psychological) and its inherent relationship with other forms of violence, uncoiling a radical critique of the punitive State and the dynamics of growing criminalisation. Consequently, it aims to foster the search for new horizons of justice and trace tools and strategies which, rather than weaken, strengthen the capacity to do and weave together.
When we think of the lives of specific women, and the conflicts, paradoxes and challenges of their daily life, what comes to light immediately is the systemic dimension and complex framework of the different forms of violence they face. This violence is articulated permanently and simultaneously on multiple levels: implosion in domestic spaces; the disciplining of bodies on the streets via social and punitive institutions; the regulated movement of people between countries; violence operating as a principle of authority in working-class areas; the plundering of common land and resources; the exploitation and appropriation of vital energy; and the colonisation of futures through the financialisation of social life.
The programme This Violence Which Is Not One. Taking Back the Power Stolen from Us is the continuation of two encounters held previously in the Museo Reina Sofía: the session Situated Research in Contexts of Violence, as part of the Critical Node Militant Research, from the Museo Reina Sofía’s Study Programme Connective Tissue, and In the Spider’s Web. Children, Institutional Violence and Feminist Horizons of Justice. Furthermore, it completes the initiatives driven by La Laboratoria, Weakening Violence. The School of Popular Feminisms, and the same-titled publication Esa violencia que no es una. Movimiento feminista, Estado punitivo y otros horizontes de justicia (This Violence Which Is Not One. The Feminist Movement, Punitive State and Other Horizons of Justice, La Laboratoria, 2024).
Participants
Luci Cavallero is a lesbo-feminist activist, a member of the Ni Una Menos (Not One Woman Less) collective and a participant in the organisation of 8M in Argentina. Her concerns revolve around issues of debt, gender and economic violence, and she is the co-author of Una lectura feminista de la deuda (Tinta Limón, 2021) and La casa como laboratorio. Finanzas, vivienda y trabajo esencial (Tinta Limón, 2022).
Viviana Dipp Quitón is a lawyer and feminist activist and a member of the Madrid 8M Commission’s Migration and Anti-racism Committee.
Susana Draper is a writer and teacher from Uruguay. She lectures at Princeton University and lives in Harlem (New York), where she participates in different feminist collectives and in the fight to abolish the prison system. She is the author of Libres y sin miedo. Horizontes feministas para construir otros sentidos de justicia (Tinta Limón, 2023).
Fernanda Martins is a professor of Law at the Universidade Federal de Santamaria (UFSM) in Brazil, a researcher in criminology and an activist for the abolition of prisons. She is the author of Feminismos criminológicos (Editores del Sur, 2023).
Adilia de las Mercedes is a feminist legal expert and an expert in critical criminology, strategic litigation, teaching and legislative development for human rights. Furthermore, she has investigated femicides and sexual violence in situations of conflict.
Heidy Mieles and Mariana Collaguazo are members of Mujeres de Frente, a care and cooperation community against established punishment in Quito, Ecuador, between female prisoners, former female inmates, self-employed street traders, urban waste recyclers, female workers paid by the job, students and teachers, children, and teenagers.
Miren Ortubay is a legal expert and researcher who backs the reduction of the penal system from a non-punitive feminism.
Helena Silvestre is a peripheral writer, favela feminist, editor of the magazine Amazonas and a member of the Escola Feminista Abya Yala (São Paulo). Her publications most notably include Cochichos de amor e outras alquimias (Txai, 2023) and Notas sobre el hambre (Avenate, 2024).
Sindicato de inquilinas e inquilinos de Madrid is a self-organised collective that fights for the right to fair and affordable housing rents and for a neighbourhood life with guarantees and rights, and against rent-seeking and real estate speculation.
Territorio Doméstico is a trans-border collective made up of domestic and care workers and their struggle.
Programa
5pm Feminist Strategies and Narratives Opposite Violence
— Conversation between Luci Cavallero, Viviana Dipp Quitón and Helena Silvestre
6:15pm The War from Below and Our Struggle against the Punitive State
— Conversation between Susana Draper, Fernanda Martins and Mujeres de Frente (Mariana Collaguazo and Heidy Mieles)
7:30pm Discussion
Nouvel Building, Protocol Room
150 people
Free, until full capacity is reached
11am Confronting Violence. What Can We Learn from Prison Abolition?
— Workshop with Susana Draper, in conversation with Adilia de las Mercedes and Miren Ortubay
According to Françoise Vergès, the fight against violence cannot evade the critique of violence that the State fosters and legitimises, nor can it escape that which relates to feminist grievances directed at the State’s judicial system. The first step to moving towards new horizons of justice lies in keeping the focus on the radical critique of the punitive, sexist and racist State and its oppressive dynamics. This three-hour workshop threads together practices, struggles, reflections and tools in a commitment to jointly imagining these horizons, as well as the possible responses to violence beyond the judicial and penal system.
Nouvel Building, Protocol Room
30 people
6pm The Debt Is Owed to Us. Organising against Financial Looting
— Conversation between Luci Cavallero, Territorio Doméstico and Sindicato de inquilinas e inquilinos de Madrid
Starting from the slogan “The Debt Is Owed to Us”, born out of the 2020 Feminist Strike in Argentina, this discussion reflects on how debt has become a device to plunder and control our lives, raising questions around other kinds of debt (colonial, care-based) to place on the table strategies of organisation against financial looting and forms of wealth distribution created among us all.
Nouvel Building, Protocol Room
50 people
Free, until full capacity is reached